With a voice that blends raw power with delicate vulnerability, Sydnie Christmas has quickly proven herself to be one of the West End’s brightest rising stars.
Her performance of “She Used to Be Mine” from the hit musical Waitress at Musical Con 2024 left audiences breathless, cementing her reputation as not just a singer, but a storyteller of the highest order.
From the opening lines, Christmas approached the Sara Bareilles ballad like a whispered prayer, her delivery intimate yet commanding.
As the song built toward its emotional climax, her sky-high notes sent shivers through the crowd, each phrase packed with a depth of feeling that resonated far beyond the stage. By the time she reached the final refrain, many in the audience were visibly wiping away tears, overwhelmed by the honesty and pain she poured into every lyric.
While countless performers have covered this modern Broadway standard, Christmas’s rendition stood apart for its authenticity. She didn’t just sing the words—she lived them in real time, turning the story of heartbreak and resilience into something deeply personal.
Fans in attendance described it as “pure magic,” with one praising her as a “once-in-a-lifetime talent” whose performances “always give me shivers up and down my spine.” Others called her “unbelievable,” “phenomenal,” and “a true generational voice.”
Even those watching through less-than-perfect fan recordings online were moved to tears, with one listener admitting, “I had to watch this with the sound off, and I still got the sniffles.” Another wrote, “She doesn’t have to run all over the stage in a bikini.
All you need is a magic voice.” The reaction was unanimous: Sydnie Christmas had turned a beloved ballad into something unforgettable, elevating it with the kind of passion and artistry that only she can bring.
Her performance at Musical Con was more than just a highlight of the festival—it was a reminder of her remarkable ability to connect with audiences on the deepest level. With each note, Christmas reaffirmed that she is not simply singing; she is telling stories, healing hearts, and carving her place among the greats of modern musical theatre.
What to know about “She Used to Be Mine” from Waitress
Written by Grammy-winning artist Sara Bareilles, “She Used to Be Mine” is the emotional centerpiece of the Broadway musical Waitress. The song captures the pain of loss, the struggle of self-identity, and the quiet strength of rediscovery.
Since the show’s debut in 2015, the ballad has become a modern standard, covered by countless vocalists for its demanding range and soul-stirring lyrics. Sydnie Christmas’s rendition at Musical Con 2024 joins a legacy of unforgettable interpretations, earning praise as one of the most moving performances of the song to date.
