On May 4, 2025, during Season 23 of American Idol, Jamal Roberts, a 27-year-old P.E. teacher from Meridian, Mississippi, delivered a spirited rendition of Carrie Underwood’s hit song “Undo It” as part of the show’s “Ladies’ Night” theme. The performance was notable not only for Roberts’ energetic delivery but also because Underwood herself, now serving as a judge on the show, was present to witness his interpretation of her song.
“Undo It,” co-written by Underwood, Kara DioGuardi, Marti Frederiksen, and Luke Laird, was released as the third single from Underwood’s third studio album, Play On, in 2010. The song achieved commercial success, selling over 1.6 million copies in the United States and becoming one of Underwood’s top-performing singles. Its catchy chorus and rock-infused country sound have made it a fan favorite and a staple in Underwood’s live performances.
Roberts’ performance received a mixed response from fans and critics. Some viewers felt that his rendition lacked the vocal power and emotional depth of the original, suggesting that he may have “done himself a disservice” by choosing such a challenging song. Others, however, appreciated his enthusiasm and stage presence, noting that he brought a fresh energy to the performance.
Despite the varied reactions, Roberts advanced to the Top 8 of the competition, demonstrating his resilience and versatility as a performer. His journey on American Idol has been marked by a willingness to take risks and tackle diverse musical styles, qualities that have endeared him to both the judges and the viewing audience.
He considers Carrie a “strong woman.” He loves the chorus. Miranda stresses that he needs to put his own spin on it. He’s leaving the “uh uh uh” to the background singers. But Miranda helps him bring more of the chorus into his performance.
Jamal never disappoints. Tonight is no different. He plays off the background singers during the chorus, which was a smart decision. It adds more heft to the performance. He’s owning the stage as he adds his own growly adlibs. He’s literally standing in line with the background vocalists as he finishes the song. Very well staged.
Luke tosses his hat to Carrie to wear. Lionel says, “You are mesmerising and I love it.” Carrie notes some missed lyrics but says “WHO CARES.” I didn’t even notice. Her fans probably did. – Text 12 to 21523
Watch the video down below and don’t forget to share this beautiful song with your friends and family…
