Joe Henley delivered another impressive performance on The Voice Monday night, earning praise from all four coaches and securing his place in the Season 30 Top 10. However, his latest song choice sparked a debate among fans, with many suggesting different songs they would like to hear him perform next.
The 19-year-old Team Riley singer took the stage on November 16 during the second part of Y2K Night. With a spot in the Top 10 on the line, Henley chose Lee Ann Womack’s “I Hope You Dance,” giving viewers a chance to hear a different side of his voice.

Henley appeared comfortable on stage and received a standing ovation from all four coaches for the second week in a row. His coach, Riley Green, was especially impressed.
“Joe, you crushed it, man,” Green told him. “You’re one of the most naturally talented people on this show.”
Green also praised Henley’s improvement throughout the competition and his ability to step up whenever he gets an opportunity.
As the final performer of the night, Henley had only a short time left before voting closed. Still, he received enough support to advance and secure a place in the Top 10.
Watch his performance below.
Fans Want Joe Henley to Try More Country Songs
Many fans continue to believe Henley has what it takes to win Season 30. However, several viewers think he should return to traditional country songs or try something more upbeat to show a different side of his voice.
One fan suggested, “Come on let him sing an upbeat song. Something like ‘All my ex’s live in Texas, ‘Amarillo by morning’…..by George Strait.”
Another viewer had a different classic in mind, writing, “He would crush ‘Keeper of the Stars’ by Tracy Byrd.”
Randy Travis was another popular suggestion among fans. One viewer commented, “He really needs to sign a Randy Travis song. He’s got the voice to pull it off.”
Others wanted to hear Henley tackle a more energetic country hit. “He needs to be given now a spicy song to show that he can handle it. He can! Like a Josh Turner, or Trace Adkins,” one fan wrote.
Not everyone was focused on his next song, though. Some viewers simply wanted to make sure Henley knew how much they enjoyed his performance.
“Joe Henley has ‘the VOICE’,” one supporter commented.
Another shared an emotional reaction, writing, “I started to tear up and just felt such emotion in my stomach. He connects so naturally it is so unusual.”
Despite the requests for different song choices, many fans remain convinced Henley is a serious contender for the Season 30 title. One viewer even declared, “He’s my favorite but that song was not for him!”

What’s Next for Joe Henley?
Henley will return to the stage on Monday, November 23, for Dolly Parton Tribute Night. The remaining contestants will perform songs from the country legend’s catalog as Season 30 moves closer to its December 14 finale.
With a place in the Top 10 secured, Henley has another opportunity to impress viewers. Fans will be waiting to see which song Riley Green chooses for him next and whether it will give the young singer a chance to explore more of his country sound.