Joe Henley delivered another strong performance on The Voice Monday night, but his latest song choice left some fans divided.
The 19-year-old Team Riley singer took the stage on November 16 as the show wrapped up its Top 13 round with the second part of Y2K Night. Competing for one of the final spots in the Top 10, Henley chose Lee Ann Womack’s “I Hope You Dance,” a surprising pick that gave him a chance to show a different side of his voice.

While some contestants appeared nervous during their first live performances, Henley seemed comfortable under pressure. His performance earned a standing ovation from all four coaches for the second week in a row.
Riley Green was especially proud of his artist.
“Joe, you crushed it, man,” Green told him. “You’re one of the most naturally talented people on this show.”

Green also praised how much Henley has improved throughout the competition and how he continues to step up when given an opportunity.
Henley performed last on Monday night, leaving fans only a few minutes to vote before the voting window closed. However, the late performance did not stop him from getting enough support. He advanced to the next round and secured a place in the Top 10.
Watch his performance below.
Fans Are Divided Over Joe Henley’s Song Choice
Although many fans continue to support Henley as a potential winner, some questioned whether “I Hope You Dance” was the right song for him.
“He’s the best but this wasn’t the right song for him!!! He absolutely should win but he needs to do a better job picking songs!!!” one fan wrote.
Another viewer agreed, commenting, “Not the right song choice but he sang it well in his low register.”

Some fans also felt the background guitar was too loud and took attention away from Henley’s voice. One viewer said the song was not the best fit for him, even though Joe had been a favorite from the beginning.
Others continued to praise the young singer and his performance.
“He’s been my choice to win since I first heard him sing and he definitely has the Voice!” one fan commented.
“My favourite is Joe,” another wrote, while someone else simply said, “He was great.”
Fans also began suggesting songs they would like to hear from Henley next. One wanted him to sing “Friends in Low Places,” while another suggested Craig Morgan’s “Almost Home.” A different fan asked him to return to a Travis Tritt song.

What’s Next For Joe Henley?
With his place in the Top 10 secured, Henley will return to the stage next Monday, November 23, for Dolly Parton Tribute Week. The remaining artists will perform songs from the country legend’s catalog as the competition moves closer to its finale.